Forum:Reorganização de todo o Uncycs: Episódio: Deixando Carlb

Origem: Desciclopédia, a enciclopédia livre de conteúdo.
Ir para navegação Ir para pesquisar
Fórum da Desciclopédia
Boteco > Reorganização de todo o Uncycs: Episódio: Deixando Carlb
quinta-feira, 25/02/2021, 11h34min

Mais de 30 dias desde a última edição

Evite conflitos de edição


Introduction[editar]

Hello I am a user of Uncyclopedia. Portuguese is not a first language to me so sorry. I think it is time to consider leaving UncycloMedia which is Carlb.

The reasoning is the following:

  • The servers have many many downtime especially compared to Miraheze and Uncyclopedia.co where some other languages move to after Wikia closed down.
  • The support from Carlb can take a very long time and Portugese community make very clear complaints of this.
  • The Carlb servers often have many technical problems that are not present elsewhere.
  • Outdated MediaWiki installs with other projects frequently updated.
  • No SSL support on some UncycloMedia servers.
  • Difficult to manage some aspects of a wiki without Carlb intervene such as Abuse Filter.

I know a lot of Uncyclopedia use Carlb but I dont think its a good option any longer. I think projects should choose one of the following and work to make the move:

  • Miraheze
  • Uncyclopedia.co
  • Shout Wiki
  • Independent Hosting

Comparisons[editar]

Here are the brief comparisons to help you choose the right place.

Points\Choices Miraheze uncyclopedia.co independent Shout Wiki Carlb's
current Uncycs Italian, Polish, Chinese, etc. The English Uncyc/Illogico Russian, Two of the Germans, etc. None Many
MW versions Yes check.svg 1.33.0 1.32.1 depends 1.32.2 X mark.png 1.31
CentralAuth Yes check.svg Yes X mark.png No X mark.png No Something alike, but not exactly X mark.png No
Phabricator Yes check.svg Yes Yes check.svg Yes X mark.png No X mark.png No X mark.png No
Global AbuseFilter Yes check.svg Yes Yes check.svg Yes Yes check.svg Yes X mark.png No X mark.png No
Local AbuseFilter Yes check.svg Yes Yes check.svg Yes Depends Yes check.svg Yes Yes, but blocking is not allowed
Spambots Few Few Depends Few Few
Common Image repository Yes check.svg Yes (Miraheze commons) X mark.png No (or not working) X mark.png No Yes check.svg Yes Yes check.svg Yes
Instant Commons (images from Wikimedia Commons) Yes check.svg Yes Yes check.svg Yes Depends Yes check.svg Yes Yes check.svg Yes
Errors few few Depends, but generally likely Few X mark.png often
Tech-Supports Yes check.svg fast not too slow Depends not too slow X mark.png very slow
Easy management of Extensions, Namespaces, Logos, and Permissions by local crats (Special:ManageWiki) Yes check.svg Yes X mark.png No X mark.png No X mark.png No X mark.png No
Custom domain names (example.org instead of example.wikia.com or example.miraheze.org) Yes check.svg Yes Unknown Yes check.svg Yes X mark.png No Yes check.svg Yes (various .org's already registered)
Downloadable XML and image dumps On manual request No On manual request (for example database dump from Polish community) On manual request Yes (download.uncyc.org)
License Yes check.svg Choosable by the locals Needs sysadmins help
Uncyc is CC-BY-NC-SA
Depends CC-BY-SA CC-BY-NC-SA (bjaodn.org is GFDL)
Advertisements Yes check.svg No Yes check.svg No Depends Yes check.svg No Yes check.svg No

Discussion[editar]

And if you have any further questions you may feel invited to chat with us here. Please discuss here 2804:D41:A195:7500:4052:489A:4239:C4FF (discussão) 23h43min de 31 de julho de 2019 (-03)

Epa, essa discussão está em lugar errado. Please, go to the Uncyclomedia wiki, and state your idea there.Clique aqui e envie uma mensagem Smalkade ctrbssndbx7 594Setembro de 2019 08h07min de 1 de agosto de 2019 (-03)

E parece que a discussão já começou há décadas. Clique aqui e envie uma mensagem Smalkade ctrbssndbx7 594Setembro de 2019 08h12min de 1 de agosto de 2019 (-03)

Goodbye and Chuck Norris bless you April.gifCleric.pngArDq./GEN. UltraJohnnÿ O SYSOP LOUCO! 38 568 edições 11h58min de 3 de agosto de 2019 (-03)

If you wanna change the host, just go for it yourselves. We have no interest in leaving Carlb. I don't know what you mean by "Portuguese community". Most of our users, probably more than 99%, are Brazilian. Agome89 SADoi 12h13min de 3 de agosto de 2019 (-03)

Leave Carlb? You serious? Nah, you can't be that serious.

Hope you have posted this in other Carlb's wikis, they should hit the road. Hatmoji.png 17h45min de 14 de agosto de 2019 (-03)